Archived Story

A matter of time… and risk [UPDATED]

Published 11:15am Monday, April 16, 2012 Updated 11:25am Monday, April 16, 2012

On April 2, the Fergus Falls City Council rejected a proposal to redevelop the Regional Treatment Center property. However, it didn’t close the door on development plans altogether.

Instead, several council members said they were open to other plans to save the property’s historic Kirkbride building, including the possible plans of the six other developers who had expressed interest in the project but did not submit proposals by the city’s Feb. 1 deadline.

According to many of those developers, they could still be interested, but putting together a proposal could be hard if the city doesn’t give them more time than it did during the previous development round.

“I think time was definitely a factor,” said Grant Carlson, owner of Minneapolis-based real estate developer Blue Limit, one of the six other entities that submitted a letter of interest about the RTC to the city. “Time always seems to be a factor on these things.”

The last time around, developers were first allowed to see the city’s request for proposals on August 1, 2011. Letters of interest were due by Nov. 18, and a proposal was due by Feb. 1. For many developers, that timeline of two and a half to six months just was too short to line everything up for a satisfactory project.

“Anytime that we’re putting our names on something, we want to be proud of what we’re putting our names on,” said Carlson.

“When you’re running a business and working full time and on top of that you’re also doing a potential development project, it took a lot of time,” said Eric Dunn, chairman of independent film company ECTOFi Productions, which also submitted a letter of interest.

Dunn, who had made a tentative deal with would-be developer Atul Wahi to locate an ECTOFi office in the proposed “Global XChange Village,” noted that he understood why Wahi’s initial proposal was short on details in some places.

“In the time frame the city allowed, it was almost impossible to have a full development regiment (submitted),” he said.

Though time was cited as a factor by most of the developers, risk was another significant factor for many, like the New York-based Phoenix Tree Company.

“It takes a lot of money of course to build up that property,” said Phoenix Executive Director David Newman, noting that it’s hard to find investors to take on such a large project in an uncertain economy. “That was a big issue for sure, and I think time was a factor.”

In agreement was developer Mike Brady, who submitted a letter of interest with business partner Tom Gump. Brady said the Great Recession has caused a shift in thinking.

“What we would say is we’ve become wiser; maybe another person would say we’ve become more cautious,” said Brady, adding, “We would have to have some things in place before we would be able to bite off a project like that.”

Many of the developers noted that the city might need to take on a little more risk to get a project done. Some questioned whether the city’s requirement that Wahi provide the city with $5 million up front was reasonable or even possible for many developers.

“I don’t think anybody’s going to do that,” said Fergus Falls developer Craig Gantner, whose plan involved converting the RTC in phases to a residential-based building with some retail on site.

Gantner said a big reason why he didn’t submit a project was because he wasn’t confident the city officials would accept it as legitimate. Gantner said he’s approached the city about RTC redevelopment options before, and “it’s been very hard to get to any level (where) they thought you were serious about anything.”

Gantner and other developers said that it would be helpful for the city to have a dialogue with potential developers about what sort of expectations the city has for the site, allowing them to better shape their proposals.

Other issues cited by some developers included the concern that the RTC parcels purchased over a year ago by Campus Development Group have not been developed, as well as uncertainty of the city’s willingness to be flexible with developer needs.

Still, all of the developers expressed an appreciation for the RTC. Many have been following the development process over the last few months, and several stated that they might at least consider coming back with another proposal if the process opens up again.

“I’m certainly not a pessimist when it comes to the project,” said Newman. “Sometimes challenges take a lot of effort and trying over and over again.”

Global Athlete Village President Stephanie Smith declined to comment.

  • Gene Schmidt

    I enjoyed reading this yesterday in Sunday’s paper edition. Thanks for getting it online for out of town friends. Good job – valid points by developers.

  • nanajean

    Thanks Ryan, it is good to see why the RFP process hasn’t worked in this case. I hope the powers that be understand this, and correct it.

  • markcasper

    Ridiculous. The ugly memory has been closed for 3 years now, wrecking ball and bulldoze the whole place, turn it into a park. In memorial to the 2-3000 buried up there and the thousands more who were patients and or worked there. All deserve our sympathy.

    • nanajean

      And just who are you to refer to it that way. Man some of you are really dinks in this town, starting with some of the council members!

    • Frizzel

      I agree. It is always the best route of action to take when one doesn’t care for the history of certain events. Get rid of them so no one can learn what happened and be educated as to why some of the mistakes made should not happen again. Just pretend it was never there! Also, what you fail to bring up is the good that the hospital served. From the many nurses, doctors and volunteers who worked there to the thousands that once lived there that could be wonderful people. How about keeping the building up in tribute to them? Plus, this is a LANDMARK in Fergus. What else makes this town more unique than say Alexandria or DL? Nothing unless you think Westridge Dump (sorry, Mall) is a good example. Seriously, some of you people need to pull your heads out of the sand. Preserve what you have and embrace the possibilities of these buildings. Just because one developer doesn’t pan out doesn’t mean the next won’t.

  • Swedegirl

    I agree with Mark. The fact that the City wants to keep this place alive is both offensive and disgusting. Tear it down.

    • Frizzel

      So anything that is offensive and disgusting should be destroyed? Would southern plantations fall under this thought of yours? How about our nations capital? Some of the actions that are done there daily are offensive and disgusting. As I stated before, there have been wonderful things done there as well. I was up there as a child to visit and witnessed caring staff and doctors actually taking care of the residents. Just because something in the past is not what we like to remember doesn’t mean that it is all bad and should be forgotten. Learn from the mistakes and embrace the good. Use this building to grow the city, not as a future golf course or strip mall.

  • nanajean

    Are you sure their heads are in the sand? At the last meeting it was clearly stated that they were going to contact the developers to see if something could be worked out, and WHAM they have demo people come in to get ready for tear down…. Never mind that there is $$40,000,000 sitting there for getting it cleaned up, and maybe bring jobs in here. They could have spent that money on a marketer instead of getting this bid. Also if they weren’t in such a hurry to get rid of the incinerator there would have been heat in the building, and no decay from being closed up. It is plain Stupidity!

Editor's Picks

School board approves 4 of 11 bids for facility upgrades

The Fergus Falls school board approved four out of the 11 Facility Bond Referendum bids in its Monday evening meeting. The approved bids were for ... Read more

Balance of power makes GOP, Democrats wary

ST. PAUL — The Minnesota Legislature doesn’t begin its new session for another six weeks, but some lawmakers are already speculating about the potential for ... Read more

Tablets for tables: Tech changes Applebee’s dining experience

Want to order a meal at Applebee’s? There’s an app for that. Applebee’s patrons can now order and pay for meals with touch-screen tablets available ... Read more

FF man assaulted, robbed [UPDATED]

A 51-year-old Fergus Falls man was assaulted and robbed while walking on College Way near KFC and Hardee’s Saturday afternoon. The man was approached by ... Read more