Archived Story

Solution to healthcare reform elusive [UPDATED]

Published 8:04am Monday, April 9, 2012 Updated 10:04am Monday, April 9, 2012

Based on the last week’s back-and-forth between U.S. Supreme Court justices, it appears the federal health care bill is likely to be trashed.

And it means that Michelle Bachmann, Rush Limbaugh and others can crow about how all of our personal liberties are now saved because we are now not forced to buy health insurance.

My answer to that is, wonderful. So now what do we do?

If there’s one thing that everyone can agree on, it’s that health care in the United States is too expensive — for businesses, for individuals, for health insurance companies, even for doctors.

If costs continue to climb at the exponential rate they are, that 1 percent of the population that is wealthy may be the only ones who can afford health care.

Why health care costs have gone up, of course, is under great debate. Here are a few explanations I have heard:

• Hospitals are eating the costs of those without health insurance coming into emergency rooms. Anyone who has had to pay an emergency room bill understands this. In order to make up the losses, hospitals have to raise prices elsewhere.

• Drug, device and other medical product companies are engaged in price gouging. Again, in order to pay for such high prices, hospitals and clinics have to raise prices elsewhere.

• A lack of malpractice tort reform has resulted in higher and higher malpractice insurance premiums for doctors, which increases the salary demands hospitals and clinics need to pay, which again, forces hospitals and clinics to increase prices.

Fear of malpractice, I have heard, also prompts many doctors to order tests that aren’t always necessary.

• Older Americans on Medicare are getting expensive surgeries and procedures, and Medicare does not fund hospitals and clinics enough to pay for them. Thus, hospitals and clinics charge the rest of us to make up the difference.

• Administrative inflation. I have heard things like a lack of electronic records and a bureaucratic system as culprits for the massive costs.

• In general, America is getting older and more obese, and older, more obese people in general have more health problems than younger, non-obese people do.

• The nature of insurance. When you think a car or lawn mower is too expensive, you shop around, because the money comes out of your pocket. If insurance is paying for something, you don’t worry about it at best, and glaze over it at worst.

Of course, there are many other theories as to why health care, and health care insurance, is so expensive.

So I say to the Republicans out there so stridently opposed to “ObamaCare,” I put my hands in the air and ask you to solve the issue for me.

Make my and everyone else’s health insurance premiums and my co-pays cheaper, and make sure that everything health-care related gets covered.

But you better make sure your grandmothers don’t get short-changed on coverage. And you can’t make anyone who doesn’t want health insurance — even though they might need it someday — buy it.

And you have to ensure that, by making health care cheaper, you don’t put clinics, hospitals and every other company that provides health care products or services out of business.

Good luck with that.

Someone who has leaned Republican said to me the other day, “I’m not sure there is a solution.”

I can tell you this — if politics can’t be taken out of the equation, then I guarantee there won’t be one.


Joel Myhre is The Journal’s publisher. E-mail him at

  • Swede

    What is price “gouging”? Is selling pharmaceuticals at a high enough price to cover years of red tape to get the product to market “gouging”? Companies have gone bankrupt waiting for approval of new drugs. Regulation is detrimental to competition; an upstart does not have nearly the resources to cover the cost of approvals that a large company does. Competition drives down price. The free market is always the answer to reducing costs. The free market is also the answer to improved drugs and medical treatment.

    Government is force.

    • Walt Henry

      Mike, setting aside the thalidomide crisis of the late ’50′s, you might have been too young to remember or have gotten too old and forgotten, Hormone Replacement Therapy is enough to make a rational person wonder if the FDA is restrictive enough. Pfizer has set aside $1,000,000,000 (yes that many zeros)to settle 8,500 lawsuits against them for the formulation and dosage recommendations for their HRT drugs. It is not likely to be enough. It is estimated that upwards of 30% of all breast cancers in this country in the 1990′s and early 2000′s were CAUSED by their drugs. Forgetting about compensating women for the loss of their breasts or the disfigurement, think what the medical costs of treatment were generated by their lust for profits. Each cancer victim, and there were many more than 8,500, probably recieved over $100,000 in treatments. If you have health insurance, you paid for this.

  • Walt Henry

    Joel, a bit of a correction–doctors and hospitals don’t “eat” the costs of providing care to those who won’t or can’t pay. They add those expenses to the insurance premimums and bills of those who can. We are already paying for the health care of others, or at least I am and anyone like me who has health insurance. There are estimates that $12 of every $100 you are billed goes to pay for the unisured or underinsured.

Editor's Picks

Burris sentenced to 12 years, 6 months in prison

Michael Alan Burris, who pleaded guilty in October to second-degree involuntary murder in the 2012 shooting of his nephew, Scott Burris, was sentenced Friday afternoon ... Read more

Tree of Hope brings Christmas to the needy

Hundreds of ornaments hung on a tree in Bethlehem Lutheran Church before people in the congregation picked them out to take home over the weeks ... Read more

All aboard! Santa is coming to town [UPDATED]

Off in the distance will be the sound of a train’s horn, and as it chugs closer and closer, the crowd waiting his arrival will ... Read more

Send a veteran a card this season

Addressing the annual family Christmas cards can be a chore, but the local veterans’ home is asking everyone to add a couple names to the ... Read more